Welcome to Plum Tomato Pizzeria
Plum Tomato Pizzeria, located in Tarpon Springs, Florida, is a charming mom-and-pop Italian restaurant that offers an authentic dining experience. Renowned for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, customers rave about the delicious meat lovers pizza and exceptional pasta dishes. The welcoming staff creates a family-friendly atmosphere, ensuring every guest feels at home. Signature items like bruschetta and mussels in white wine sauce showcase their culinary expertise. Diners appreciate the genuine care and attentiveness of the team, making each visit memorable. Whether you choose takeout or dining in, Plum Tomato Pizzeria promises a delightful journey through Italy’s flavors.
Plum Tomato Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Looking for a good ma and pa pizza place. We are here on vacation and found this place. We got the meat lovers pizza. It was so good! Fresh meat on the pizza is not imitation. Would recommend a thousand times. Wish we had them back home in PA!
This place never disappoints! Great amazing Italian food. We love their pizza &usually get take out. We dined in for Italian pasta dishes. It's so delicious. Weekdays usually less busy but they were still packed. If you like brushetta, it's the best around. Go early if you wanna dine in or be patient, it'll be worth the wait.
'Mom-n-Pop' restaurant great food/prices/family atmosphere. Breakfast, lunch and some days dinner. Always welcomed like old friends!
Let's start with the food. AMAZING. The staff is GENUINELY interested in your palate and likeness. The cooks Emanuel and Miguel were very accommodating to or family/gathering that were...a bit of a pain . I was met with accommodation and empathy that their sincere goal was to provide excellent food and service. Meet with Gigi I felt at home. I've always been a pick up customer, so she didn't necessarily "have" to greet me. She made my visit great as I waited for my pick up order. Now. Let's talk about Toula. This GORGEOUS and intuitive woman takes you in like family and ensures that you are not only satisfied with your order, but leave with a smile. I absolutely did. This establishment is beyond expectations. Thank you!!!!
First time there Friday evening and mussels in white wine sauce and shrimp n past vodka sauce was amazing!! Authentic Italian cuisine
This little restaurant was SO good!! It's a little hole in the wall place that I cannot recommend enough! I had cauliflower pizza. So thin and crispy. We had salad and bruschetta. Alfredo. Lasagna. Everything was delicious!! Parking is limited but worth fighting for. Do it! Go!!
This was what's referred to as a " Drive By". My neighbor told me about the Plum Pizzeria in Anclote. The previous day is checking out the fishing areas for the first time. Decided the morning to actually fish the area and to try out the pizzeria. I was hungry. But the best part was my server GIGi and the owner, Andy. This place is Top Drawer!! My Mulberry Pizza was Uber! But what really impressed and inspired was the owner Andy. He was hands on! I sat at the counter and watched him work and to find out he was the owner and working that hard with a smile was epic. We shared likeminded "juju". For folks who never head it, it's a euphemism for one having good energy. I loved not only the restaurant but the man who Knows His Why? In what he does. Thank you brother for the love which is also demonstrated in the staff's interactions.
Really good wings, but I'm tired of businesses being cheap with the amount of blue cheese dipping sauce they give out. If I order six wings, I want more than just a tiny bit of sauce. Especially when I order 12.
Location
-
1988 Pinellas Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689, United States Hotline: +1 727-944-3330
Welcome to the delightful world of Plum Tomato Pizzeria, a charming gem nestled in Tarpon Springs, Florida. Located at 1988 Pinellas Ave, this delightful establishment is more than just a pizza place; it is a haven for Italian cuisine lovers. With a reputation built on authenticity and a family atmosphere, Plum Tomato Pizzeria embodies the spirit of classic Italian dining while offering that warm 'mom-and-pop' feel that makes every visit special.
Let’s talk pizza first! If customers' reviews are anything to go by, Plum Tomato's Meat Lovers Pizza is a must-try. As Aimee Dougherty noted, the freshness of the meat shines through, avoiding the trap of imitation toppings that often plague lesser establishments. The genuine ingredients create a combination that leaves palates yearning for more. But pizza is just the beginning.
Fans of Italian fare will be delighted with the wide array of dishes that Plum Tomato offers, from sumptuous pasta creations to exquisite appetizers. Danette Kuzel raves about the bruschetta, calling it the best around, while Wanda Bonnycastle praises the mussels in white wine sauce and shrimp in vodka sauce for their authentic flavors. Each dish reflects the chefs’ commitment to quality and tradition, making every meal here a reason to celebrate.
Diners frequently mention the outstanding service provided by the staff. The warmth and hospitality resonate throughout the establishment, as Kari West expressed in her review. With team members like Gigi and Toula who make everyone feel like family, dining at Plum Tomato becomes a relational experience rather than just a meal. Emanuel and Miguel, the cooks, are noted for their ability to accommodate special requests, ensuring each guest feels valued and cherished.
Whether you’re in the mood for a relaxing dine-in experience or seeking the convenience of takeout, Plum Tomato Pizzeria has you covered. Weekdays tend to be less busy, but those visiting during peak times are encouraged to be patient—the exquisite food and welcoming atmosphere make the wait worth it. So, if you find yourself in the Tarpon Springs area, do not miss the chance to explore Plum Tomato Pizzeria, where every dish tells a story of heart, tradition, and an abiding love for food.